Sheetz milkshake calories, ranked

Sheetz's official nutrition calculator lists 28 milkshakes and Cheezecake shakes. They range from 610 calories (Blue Raspberry Milkshake - Regular, 16 fl oz.) to 1480 calories (Peanut Butter Lover Milkshake (with Reese's Peanut Butter Cups), 16 fl oz). The list below runs from lowest to highest.

Nutrition figures were captured on Sep 12, 2026 from Sheetz's calculator. Sizes differ between rows, so check the serving shown. Prices are in a separate table further down. For the current menu see the Sheetz milkshake menu, and for other foods the Sheetz nutrition calculator.

This page is independent and is not affiliated with Sheetz.

Calories, lowest to highest

1. Blue Raspberry Milkshake - Regular16 fl oz.610
2. Banana Milkshake - Regular16 fl oz.690
3. Vanilla Milkshake - Regular16 fl oz700
4. Strawberry Milkshake - Regular16 fl oz730
5. Vanilla Milkshake - Large24 fl oz760
6. Banana Milkshake - Large24 fl oz.800
7. Chocolate Milkshake - Regular16 fl oz.800
8. Classic Cheezecake Shake16 fl. oz810
9. Sh'morez Milkshake16 fl oz810
10. Blue Raspberry Cheezecake Milkshake16 fl oz.820
11. Strawberry Milkshake - Large24 fl oz830
12. Black Raspberry Milkshake - Regular16 fl oz840
13. Cherry Cheezecake Shake16 fl oz.840
14. Strawberry Fuzion Cheezecake Shake16 fl oz860
15. Firewerkz Shake1 shake (source: 1 count)880
16. Cookiez- N-Cream Milkshake - Regular16 fl oz900
17. Peanut Butter Milkshake - Regular16 fl oz900
18. Black Raspberry Milkshake - Large24 fl oz930
19. White Chocolate Raspberry Cheezecake Shake16 fl oz930
20. Sh'morez Cheezecake Shake16 fl oz960
21. Chocolate Milkshake - Large24 fl oz980
22. Caramel Brownie Cheezecake Shake16 fl oz.1010
23. Peanut Butter Milkshake - Large24 fl oz1140
24. Peanut Butter Brownie Cheezecake Shake16 fl oz1180
25. Reese's Caramel Cup Milkshake16 fl oz1220
26. Cookiez-N-Cream Milkshake - Large24 fl oz.1260
27. Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Milkshake16 fl oz1270
28. Peanut Butter Lover Milkshake (with Reese's Peanut Butter Cups)16 fl oz1480

Full ranking with fat, carbs and protein

Rank 1 is the lowest calories. Fat, carbs and protein are in grams, taken from the same record as the calories.

Starting prices: create-your-own and Cheezecake shakes

These prices come from a separate capture: Sheetz Store #748, 200 Main St, Carbondale, PA 18407, on Oct 24, 2026. Prices vary by store. A plus sign means a starting price. Names and sizes do not line up one-to-one with the calorie table above, so prices are not matched to calorie figures.

Create Your Own Shake

Cheezecake Shakes

To compare against other items, see the full Sheetz menu with prices.